Row of identical grey website layout cards with one bold, hand-crafted patterned design standing out in the middle, next to a pencil and colour swatches

Quick answer

To stop an AI-built website looking like every other one, give the AI a short design brief before it writes any code: your audience, your brand personality, two or three reference sites you like, the colours and fonts to use, and the layout ideas to avoid. Then ask for three different design directions and pick one, rather than accepting the first result. Vague prompts like “make it look amazing” push AI towards the same safe, popular layouts.

Key takeaways

  • AI models fall back on common patterns when you leave design to them.
  • A one-page brief (audience, personality, references, colours, fonts, things to avoid) changes the result more than a better model.
  • Ask for three distinct directions, then refine the best one.
  • Ban the clichés you are tired of, such as purple gradients and identical card grids.
  • Finish with a brand check: would a customer recognise this as yours without the logo?

This guide supports our main article, Anthropic’s record IPO and the share unlock test, plus Gemini 4 Neon and GPT-6.2: this week’s AI news. In it, Matt Wolfe gave three new AI models the same “build me a website that will truly impress me” prompt. Two of them, GPT-6.2 Astra and Sol, built almost the same deep-sea website, down to the wording on the buttons. Here is how to make sure your AI-built site looks like you.

📘 Main article: See the full “impress me” test and this week’s new models in our AI news round-up.

Why do AI-built websites all look the same?

AI models learn from huge numbers of existing websites, so when a prompt is open-ended they tend to choose what is most common or most “safe”. Developer Theo Brown described GPT-6.2 Astra as regressing to the mean: different people with different prompts got the same theme and even the same level name. Matt has also noticed that many vibe-coded sites share a look, like purple backgrounds, animated headline text and the same card layouts.

This is not a flaw you can fix by switching tools. It is what happens when you leave the creative decisions to the AI.

What should go in a design brief for an AI website builder?

Brief itemExample
Who it is forBusy small business owners who are new to email marketing
Brand personality (3 words)Calm, practical, friendly
What you want visitors to doJoin the email list for a free checklist
ColoursDeep navy, warm sand, one bright coral for buttons
FontsA clean sans-serif for headings, easy-to-read body text
References you likeTwo or three real sites, with what you like about each
Things to avoidPurple gradients, stock “glowing brain” images, endless card grids
Must-have sectionsSimple hero, three benefits, a short story, FAQ, sign-up form

💡 Tip: If you already have one image that captures your style, turn it into a written brief first. Our guide on turning one reference image into a visual style brief shows how.

How do I get an original design from an AI tool?

  1. Write the brief using the table above. Ten minutes is enough.
  2. Ask for three directions, each with a short description of the layout, colours and mood, before any code is written.
  3. Pick one and say why. “Direction 2, because it feels calm and personal” helps the AI keep going the right way.
  4. Lock the design rules. Ask the AI to write the chosen colours, fonts and spacing into a short style file it must follow for every page.
  5. Build one page first, review it on your phone, then build the rest.
  6. Add something only you have: your own photos, a real customer quote, a hand-drawn sketch or a local detail. These are the fastest way to look different.

What prompt can I copy?

Before writing any code, propose three clearly different design directions for a website for [business] aimed at [audience]. Brand personality: [3 words]. Main goal: [action]. Colours: [list]. Fonts: [list]. I like [reference 1] because [reason] and [reference 2] because [reason]. Avoid: [clichés]. For each direction, describe the layout, mood, colour use and one distinctive idea. Do not reuse common templates. Wait for me to choose before building.

How do I check the result looks like my brand?

  • Cover test: hide the logo. Would a regular customer know it is yours?
  • Competitor test: put a screenshot next to two competitors. Does yours stand out?
  • Phone test: most visitors arrive on mobile, so check it there first.
  • Words test: AI often reuses stock phrases. Rewrite the headline and buttons in your own voice.
  • Speed test: fancy animations can slow pages down. Remove anything that does not help visitors.

For the background to this, read our round-up of this week’s AI news, including which model showed the most design “taste”.

Frequently asked questions

Which AI model is best at website design?

In Matt Wolfe’s open “impress me” test, Gemini 4 Neon produced the most original result. But a clear design brief matters more than the model for getting a site that fits your brand.

Can I just say “make it unique”?

It rarely works. Specific instructions, real references and a list of things to avoid are much more effective.

Do I need a designer?

Not to get started. A good brief and three design directions get you a long way. A designer is worth it when your brand matters a lot or you need a full identity.

How do I stop the AI drifting from my design later?

Ask it to write your colours, fonts and spacing into a style file, and tell it to follow that file for every new page.

author avatar
Garry Knight
I'm Garry Knight, the person behind Prodify Digital. I write about email list building, email marketing, SEO, AI search and the tools that connect them. My aim is to make online marketing easier to understand, so creators and small business owners can make informed decisions about building an audience and keeping people engaged. Here you'll find straightforward guides and product reviews that explain what something does, where it fits and which limitations matter. The focus is on clear explanations and useful next steps—not hype, shortcuts or promises of easy earnings.

Leave a Reply